With great thanks to Cafterhomme for editing support, innumerable suggestions, and online conversations where these bizarre scenaria were mulled over and formed into something solid from the murky mass that existed in my mind.
Thanks also to Slothargy for the incredible artwork accompanying this tale.
Chapter 5: Dave Potter
And there the relevant manuscripts for this story end. As I said before, Michael’s diary continues, but moves onto other topics and the references to his wife and Lady Caroline are minimal, whilst Brigid’s diary simply ends. Did Michael not approve of her keeping a record of her life, or did she simply feel that there was no longer any need now that she had a voice again? Whatever the truth is, we shall never know. All we do know is that they stayed married until Brigid’s death aged 72 after which Michael lived on alone until his own death ten years later. They had four children together, two sons and two daughters, all of whom married well. All throughout their married lives, they continued to live at Kildare Hall where Brigid served as Lady Caroline’s companion right until she passed away, after which Michael moved to a cottage on the estate. Lady Caroline, of course, lived on for another fifteen years, although she never took on another companion. Michael stayed on as a tutor until all the Kildare children reached maturity, and then he took on a position with Trinity College Dublin, completing his PhD in the Religions of the Classical Lebanon.
As for the other characters, Sally left the employ of Lady Caroline once Clare was rehabilitated and established in her role as Sister Clare’s maid. Clare herself, took on the identity of one Sandra Culley and, after working at Kildare Hall for five years and imposing her vengeance for as long as had been inflicted upon her, she married a gentleman named Simon Lafferty and they moved to England soon afterwards, settling in the city of Liverpool. When she left, Sister Clare was sent back to the convent. Due to the outcry caused by the anonymous criminals who exposed all the Milk Order’s shady secrets, the regime within the convent was much altered, but it was deemed that Sister Clare, a relic of the old days, had been encased in latex for too long for it to be permanently removed and so she continued, along with all the remaining original sisters, silent, anonymous and entirely incommunicado, never once being able to express to people that she was in fact not the Clare that they thought she was. She died, still encased in latex, some twenty-three years later, one of only three remaining latex-clad Milk Sisters by that stage. No one outside the Order attended her funeral.
Then there is Love Hart, the most tragic character of all. Passive, weak-willed Love, was turned into a tool for men’s lusts whilst never being allowed to enjoy pleasure herself. What was to happen to her afterwards? There are suggestions that, when her guardianship passed to her children, Caroline would have tried to get her restored somehow but, perhaps fortunately for Love, she died within two years of Michael and Brigid’s marriage. Cause of death, a heart attack brought on, according to the doctor, by supporting the weight of such enormous breasts and other bodily modifications. Lady Kildare laid her to rest with full pomp and thousands of adoring admirers attended the funeral in Kildare Cathedral, but I think we can say quite safely that, for Love herself, it was most probably a blessed release.
Which leaves us with only one character remaining and she is, frustratingly, perhaps the most important of them all. As both a historian and a storyteller, it has been endlessly irking to me that Lady Caroline Kildare did not keep a diary nor left for posterity her own perspective on events. She is, in effect, voiceless, and yet, at the same time, reading between the lines of both Michael’s and Brigid’s accounts, that she was in many ways the prime mover behind the whole saga. And so, in the absence of an authentic voice, I shall try to piece together the fragments by myself.
It seems that, whilst confident and intelligent at school, Caroline was then but a girl. Her experiences with Michael awakened her, not only sexually, but also to the reality that her beauty and sex appeal gave her a certain power over men, a power that she enjoyed wielding and which, in a society whereby she was stripped of almost every agency, she began to crave.
Of her marriage to Lord Kildare, we can only surmise. Noble girls at that time had little to no say as to their choice of spouse; usually the candidate was presented as a fait accompli by the parents and the girl simply accepted. This may have been the case with Caroline, but the school records show that no fewer than five attendees of the school ball offered her their hand and yet Lord Kildare was the one accepted. Why was this? His noble status and extreme wealth were, of course, factors, but the other suitors were far from being minor personages too. Had her parents merely decided on Kildare and then just informed her, or had she had a role to play too? Certainly, there are no hints that she was displeased with the match, so I feel it safe to assume the latter. And why would a young woman so obviously intelligent and streetwise as her choose a man who was most obviously gay? Well, perhaps because of the freedom that choice presented? Certainly, it seems that she already has a hold over her husband by the fact that the man invited in to give them children is of her choosing. She was, to a degree, forging her own destiny.
Which leads us onto her and Michael Daly. Did she love him? Perhaps so. After all, he was the only man that she knew intimately at this stage. But I suspect, as his diaries attest, that it was his naivety and malleability that also attracted her. Here was another man that she could control and manipulate, and so it transpired. Besides, if she had wanted him all for herself, why on earth invite Sister Brigid into their home, the woman he confessed to loving?
It is my feeling that he spoke to her during their intimate times of what he had seen at the convent and this stirred something quite different in her breast. As a victim of a male-dominated society herself and someone whose sexual appetite was both large and transcending genders, the tales of the Milk Sisters intrigued, excited, and angered her. So, she invited one into her home and then got her to write about it all so she may know first-hand the reality of life behind those high walls.
And having a Milk Sister in her bed again tore her emotions. She empathised with this poor creature and yearned to help her, yet at the same time, loved having a pliant latex doll to play with. So, a solution was required and the plan with Clare and Shona was devised: she would free not one but two nuns from their bondage – and create two sycophantic lackeys in the process – and then punish a sadist for her sins whilst maintaining a Milk Sister to play with in her home.
Or at least, that is my theory.
It still leaves several questions. Firstly, His Lordship. His death was rather convenient, was it not? Who did anonymously inform the authorities about him and John Hart (a man whom Caroline cleared hated with a passion for the hell he subjected her friend to)? And since her plans would have been impossible to execute with Lord Kildare still alive, then she certainly had a motive. But to brand her a murderer is a serious allegation and not one that I am prepared to subscribe to, and so I will merely say that, sometimes, timing can be a happy accident.
Which brings our tale to a close… or almost. When I said that Caroline kept no diary and had no voice, I was not telling the full truth, for she did leave us a record of sorts. Whilst silent on every front, from the day she got married to her death decades later, she meticulously kept a secret record of all her sexual encounters. It is a fascinating read, extending to several volumes which each experience described, critiqued, and marked. Michael would be rather saddened to learn that the best he ever attained was a 5; Brigid managed an 8 on one occasion but was usually a 6 or a 7. Many more scored much higher. Over the course of her life, Caroline had literally hundred of lovers of both sexes and a few somewhere in-between. After the events described in this book, she took to spending more and more time abroad – presumably because of the freedoms allowed there – staying in luxury hotels on the French Riviera or, in the winter, at Alpine resorts, where she would often enjoy a different lover every night. And so, to close this account, I shall leave you with the words of the woman herself as, I believe, she would want to be remembered, in control, sexually fulfilled and free as a bird.
When he came back, I was combing my hair. Except for a pair of the black panties such as one finds commonly in Italian lingerie shops, I was naked. I smiled at him, a little stiffly, a little uncertain.
The water was running. In the bathroom he turned me around admiringly. I was very complaisant and moved readily to his touch. We stood beneath the shower. He nestled himself flat in the meeting of my buttocks. An excruciating douche. He was unable to move, but began to soap my breasts which glistened like seals beneath the flow of water. He scrubs my back. And then went over them with the cloth. ‘It’s good for them,’ he told me. Aureate light was reflected from the ceiling and he had a hard-on I was sure would never disappear.
He wrapped me in an enormous towel, soft as a robe, and carried me to the bed. We lay across it diagonally, and he began to draw the towel apart with care, to remove it as if it were a bandage. His hands floated onto me. The sum of small acts began to unite us, the pure calculus of love. He entered and I exhaled what felt like my final breath.
When it was over I fell asleep without a word.
9/10
21/02/2021
Copyright © 2021, Dave Potter
Final paragraph adapted from A Sport and a Pastime, James Salter